Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Clive Thorp's avatar

It is entirely misleading to compare 'wealth' with income (GDP).

A useful example illustrating this is to note that Auckland has more than 600,000 houses, and their average value is reported as $1.2m by the web just now. As a hugely conservative estimate, let's say that the owners of those houses have equity (wealth) in each house they own of $500,000 (but it's nutty otherwise to imagine that the average mortgage for them all is $700,000). The wealth of these 600,000 homeowners is at least $300,000,000,000 on these figures, ie, $300 billion. That's three times the wealth of the NBR 2025 richlisters.

Just those living in Auckland, and just their houses or those they own to rent in Auckland - not their shares, beach houses, the businesses many of them own etc.

The real power in NZ comes from the people who live in and own these houses - so I am deliberately excluding those who rent, but not those who own. These owners, collectively much more wealthy that the NBR Richlisters, each have a vote. I think it's pretty clear that they have the power in NZ, via their vote and Parliament.

Expand full comment
koreakiwi's avatar

Well said Bryce - you did well with Plunket too - he really tried hard to rattle you and you were remarkably zen + get this piece posted on the Platform to boot :)

Expand full comment
22 more comments...

No posts